What Happens During a Preliminary Hearing?
- August 5th, 2009
- Write comment
The easiest way to understand a preliminary hearing, in layman’s terms, is this: Courts have so much going on that they simply cannot afford to take every arrest/ charge through criminal proceedings. At the preliminary hearing, the evidence is reviewed to basically see if there is enough. Interestingly, many cases are dropped during the preliminary hearing because there is insufficient evidence. In the case you refer to, they will look at the evidence against this person. Videos, fingerprints, statements by witnesses, even statements made by this person during interrogation/ interview. Obviously, the items stolen will be presented. If there is enough evidence, they will continue by setting a court date. If there isn’t enough evidence, or if this persons due process rights were violated, it will be dropped.
A preliminary hearing in a felony case is conducted before a magistrate judge, at which time the prosecuting attorney presents what evidence he/she may have to show that there is probable cause (reason) to believe that a crime has been committed and that the defendant committed the crime. If the prosecutor convinces the judge with that information, the defendant is bound over, that is to say that the case is referred to the district court for further action. Should the prosecutor not make an adequate showing at the preliminary hearing, the magistrate judge may dismiss the case or the charge may be reduced to a less serious offense and the defendant is sentenced accordingly.
In a hearing to determine probable cause, a court must address two important issues. The first is whether a crime was committed within the jurisdiction of the court. State courts are usually limited in jurisdiction to the county in which they sit. Crimes that involve actions in multiple states might have proper jurisdiction in a federal rather than state court. The second issue is the finding of probable cause. The evidence presented can be physical, forensic or testimonial and is not restricted to the normal rules of evidence in a criminal trial
If a defendant is bound over to the district court on a felony charge, he/she then appears for arraignment before a district judge. At the arraignment in district court, the defendant is again advised of his/her rights and the procedures the court will follow from that time forward.
Presentence report is prepared by an investigator assigned to a case. It details important information about the defendant that will assist the judge in determining the sentence. A copy of the presentence investigation is made available to the defendant and his/her attorney, as well as to the prosecutor. By Administrative Court Rule 32, presentence reports are confidential and may not be disclosed to other parties or agencies except by court order upon a showing of legitimate interest in the rehabilitation of the defendant. The presentence report contains detailed information about the defendant’s background, social history, and other issues of a private nature to the defendant.